Classics as Choice: Canon, Language, and the Normativity of Inheritance
I. Introduction: Classics as Acts of Recognition The term classic is frequently invoked as though it designates an intrinsic and self evident quality. Works are described as timeless, authoritative, or foundational, as if their status were the natural consequence of aesthetic superiority or intellectual depth. Such descriptions obscure the historical processes through which certain texts acquire normative authority. A classic does not emerge into prominence by metaphysical necessity. It becomes classical through sustained acts of recognition, preservation, institutional endorsement, and pedagogical repetition. Its endurance may testify to its capacity to reward continued engagement, yet endurance alone does not explain centrality. Canonical status is conferred within particular historical configurations of power, education, and cultural aspiration. To speak of a canon is therefore to speak of selection. Every curriculum, every anthology, every language requirement presupposes a decisio...